June 3
Picking the wrong contractor for your Twin Cities remodeling project can turn what should be an exciting renovation into months of headaches, going over budget, and inferior work. Minnesota homeowners have hundreds of contractors to choose from in Minneapolis, St. Paul, and the suburbs, but not all deliver the quality and professionalism homeowners deserve.
Since 2013, HBRE has heard many stories of problems homeowners faced before hiring them. Learning what warning signs to watch helps homeowners avoid contractors who overpromise and underdeliver.
Some warning signs are so serious that homeowners should walk away immediately, no matter how good the sales pitch sounds.
No License or Insurance
Minnesota requires contractors to hold a license for projects over a certain threshold. If contractors cannot show current license information or proof of insurance, they operate illegally. Do not just take their word—verify licenses through the state and call insurance companies yourself to confirm coverage is active, both General Liability coverage and Workers Compensation coverage.
Pressure to Sign Right Away
Legitimate contractors don’t use high-pressure sales tactics. Lines like “this price is only good today” or “we need a decision now to fit you in the schedule” should raise instant red flags. Quality contractors understand homeowners need time to reach well-informed decisions about major investments.
HBRE’s process gives homeowners time to think through options. After initial consultations and design work, homeowners review detailed proposals free of pressure. Good contractors stay available after homeowners have had time to consider their options.
Demanding Large Upfront Deposits
Be extremely wary of contractors asking for large deposits before starting work. Payment schedules should match contract milestones: an initial deposit to get started, progress payments as work is completed, and a final payment after approval. Contractors demanding 50% or more up front often have cash flow problems or worse.
Reasonable payment structures protect both parties. Contractors get paid as work progresses. Homeowners keep leverage to make sure work meets standards before releasing full payment.
Can’t Provide References
Every established contractor should have satisfied customers willing to discuss their experience. If contractors cannot or will not provide references, they likely have reasons to hide what past clients might say.
When checking references, ask specific questions. How did the contractor deal with unexpected issues? Did they communicate regularly? Did the project finish on time and on budget? Would you hire them again?
Vague Contracts or Estimates
Contracts that use vague language like “kitchen remodel” or “bathroom update” without specifying exactly what work will be done create opportunities for disputes. Detailed contracts specify materials, work scope, payment schedules, timeframe expectations, and change order procedures.
Estimates should break down costs by category including both materials and labor/installation. Lump-sum estimates make it impossible to evaluate whether pricing is reasonable or to understand where the money goes.
Some red flags aren’t automatic deal-breakers but deserve serious consideration before moving forward.
Poor Communication from the Start
If getting answers to basic questions feels difficult before signing a contract, expect worse communication once work begins. Contractors who take days to return calls, give vague answers, or seem annoyed by questions won’t suddenly become more responsive during your project.
Quality contractors reply promptly to inquiries, answer questions clearly, and make homeowners feel like priorities rather than inconveniences.
No Physical Office or Showroom
While not every contractor needs a standalone office, the lack of a physical presence sparks questions. Where do they store materials? How long have they been in business? Can you visit to see samples or meet the team?
Established contractors with local roots have more invested in their reputation. They rely on word-of-mouth referrals from satisfied customers in the community, which incentivizes quality work and good service.
Price Change/Creep
If your estimate mysteriously increases the added costs may be legitimate or perhaps fabricated by the contractor to hide among other changes. It is not uncommon for pricing to increase as homeowners begin to design the scope of their project by adding newly desired features, upgrading finishes, etc.. You should, however, understand when and why this happens.
HBRE’s design process produces accurate estimates based on actual supplier and subcontractor bids before construction begins. For the supplier and subcontractor estimates, along with any remaining fixtures and finishes to be designed that are based on assumptions, you need to both understand and approve of the any assumptions their respective allowance allocations, if applicable. The numbers reflect what the project will actually cost, rather than rough estimates that later escalate.
Suggesting You Skip Permits
Any contractor suggesting you avoid permits to save money or time is suggesting you break the law. Permits exist to protect safety and property values. Unpermitted work creates problems when selling homes or filing insurance claims.
Quality contractors understand local permit requirements and factor permit timelines into project schedules. They handle permit applications as part of their service.
No Written Warranties
Reputable contractors stand behind their work with written warranties covering craft and materials. Contractors reluctant to provide warranties in writing are unlikely to honor them if problems arise after project completion.
HBRE provides comprehensive warranties covering work for specific periods. Clear warranty terms protect homeowners’ investments long after projects finish.
Using Only Their Own Crew
Most general contractors rely on specialized subcontractors for plumbing, electrical, HVAC, and other trades. Contractors who claim their crew handles everything regularly lack proper licensing for specialized work or use uninsured workers.
Ask about subcontractors. Established contractors work with the same licensed, insured subs repeatedly. These long-term relationships indicate contractors who value quality partnerships over just finding the cheapest labor.
Unwilling to Put Things in Writing
Everything should be documented – the contract, specifications, change orders, payment schedules, and warranties. Contractors who resist putting agreements in writing or make verbal promises they won’t document likely don’t intend to honor those commitments.
Written documentation prevents disagreements and provides recourse in the event of disputes. If something matters enough to discuss, it matters enough to document.
Asking the right questions during initial conversations helps identify contractors to avoid.
How Do You Deal with Unexpected Issues?
All remodeling projects encounter surprises – old wiring that needs updating, hidden water damage, and structural issues behind walls. How contractors respond reveals their character and competence.
Good contractors address contingency budgets, explain how they’ll communicate about issues, and show problem-solving experience. Bad contractors blame homeowners, claim surprises never happen on their jobs, or can’t articulate clear processes for handling issues.
What’s Your Timeline for My Project?
Unrealistic promises about completion times indicate either inexperience or dishonesty. Contractors promising to finish major renovations impossibly fast either don’t understand what’s involved or plan to cut corners.
Quality contractors provide realistic timelines accounting for permit approvals, material lead times, inspection schedules, and potential weather delays. They explain what factors affect timing, rather than guaranteeing that nothing will cause delays.
Who Will Be On-Site Managing the Work?
Someone should be supervising work regularly – the general contractor, a project manager, or a lead carpenter who coordinates different trades. Projects without consistent on-site management tend to have quality control issues, scheduling problems, and poor coordination between trades.
HBRE’s owners and project managers personally oversee projects to ensure work meets standards and deal with any difficulties promptly.
How Do You Handle Changes During Construction?
Change orders happen on most projects. Explicit procedures for handling changes – documenting what changed, cost impacts, timeline effects, and requiring documented approval before proceeding – protect both parties.
Contractors missing clear change-order processes either surprise homeowners with unexpected costs or absorb changes that affect quality or profitability.
Beyond specific red flags, pay attention to how you feel interacting with potential contractors. Will you feel comfortable having these people in your home for weeks or months? Do they listen to questions and reply respectfully? Does their communication manner match your preferences?
Gut feelings matter. If something appears wrong even when you can’t identify specific problems, that’s worth considering. Finding another contractor takes less time than dealing with a problematic one.
Understanding how professional contractors operate helps identify the right fit.
They offer detailed written proposals covering scope, materials, timeline, and costs. They maintain proper licensing and insurance. They communicate regularly and respond quickly. They work with established, insured subcontractors. They handle permits as standard practice. They provide written warranties. They’re reachable and accountable.
HBRE’s transparent approach to kitchen and home remodeling eliminates surprises and develops trust. The three-phase process – vision setting, design, and construction – ensures homeowners reach well-informed decisions before work begins.
Choosing the right contractor makes the difference between a remodeling project that exceeds expectations and one that causes endless frustration. Knowing which red flags to avoid helps Minnesota homeowners protect their investments and find contractors who deliver quality work and communicate honestly.
Contact HBRE to arrange a free consultation and experience what working with an established, reputable Twin Cities contractor should feel like.
Loading…